Screenshot of NMA's news clip about the Western Mom vs Chinese Mom article on WSJ.

Are Chinese mothers superior to Western mothers?

Surely by now, you have heard of the article by Amy Chua on the Wall Street Journal about why Chinese mothers are superior to Western mothers.

I have to disagree with Chua that Chinese mothers are superior.

Convincing a child to forge ahead in their endeavours and never give up is a good thing.

However, in the process of never giving up on a parent’s goals for the child, the child will grow up regretting that he or she pursued the parent’s goals and not her own in her childhood. They are experiences the child can never get back.

What Chinese parents understand is that nothing is fun until you’re good at it.
~ wsj.com

Furthermore, if children are taught that they can only have fun when they are winning, they might never try something new later on in life because they will have to lose before they can win. And win for a limited time. There will always be a bigger fish.

Being the best is not the most important … because you can never stay the best. Or if you keep on trying to be the best in one thing, you miss out on a lot of other things in life.

When I started high school, I was 12, by the time I was 14 and in grade 11, I was taking classes with 17 to 18 year olds. My parents pushed me hard to compete on par with people who were 3 years older than me, so I could get into university sooner. That was the most pointless exercise in life and I missed out most of my childhood because of that.

Learning to enjoy the journey and develop an intrinsic love for what you do is the key to being happy in life.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
  • Martin_hutnik

    I have to agree and I think a generation of kids born to chinese parents in Canada realize the importance of enjoying life and trying out new things.

    • http://dho.ca Dan H

      I think to be more specific, it might be a generation of kids born to Chinese parents … who were born in Canada. The parents born in Asia *might* still work like Amy Chua.